Everyday foods

Vegan alternatives to turkey

Seitan roast · Firm tofu · Soy curls

Swap matrix

Use these instead

For a centrepiece roast, seitan is the only substitute that carves. Tofu works for slices, sandwiches and anything shredded.

Conversion ratios

Substitute	Use this much	Good to know
Seitan roast	1 : 1	Wrap and steam, then roast for a carvable joint.
Firm tofu	1 : 1 sliced	Best for sandwich slices and stir-fries.
Soy curls	100 g dry = 250 g cooked	For shredded leftovers and pies.

Best uses

Holiday centrepiece roast
Sandwich slices with cranberry
Pies and stews from leftovers
Skewers and traybakes

Why the swap works

It delivers comparable protein per serving, so meals stay just as filling.

Where it does not work

A seitan roast dries out in an uncovered oven. Steam it first and baste it, or it turns rubbery.

Kitchen notes

Stuff the seitan roast with a herb and chestnut filling for a proper centrepiece.
Baste with olive oil, soy sauce and sage every 15 minutes.
Rest for 10 minutes before carving, exactly as you would a bird.

The numbers

Swapping one kilo saves about 9 kg CO₂e. Do it once a week for a year and you avoid roughly 117 kg CO₂e — the same as driving a petrol car 585 km.

Sources: Poore & Nemecek (Science, 2018), FAO, USDA FoodData Central, Mekonnen & Hoekstra (2011).

Common questions

What is a vegan alternative to a turkey roast?

A stuffed seitan roast, steamed then oven-roasted, or a shop-bought wellington built on mushroom and chestnut.

Can you carve seitan?

Yes. Steaming the dough before roasting gives it a firm, sliceable grain.

What about the gravy?

Build it on browned onion, mushroom stock, soy sauce and a spoon of Marmite for depth; thicken with flour or cornflour.

Convert this recipe

Paste an ingredient list and we will rewrite the animal ingredients as vegan ones, with quantities kept as written.

Vegan alternatives to beef →Vegan alternatives to beef →Vegan alternatives to chicken →Vegan alternatives to bacon →Vegan alternatives to pork →Vegan alternatives to lamb →

Back to all swaps

In depth

The longer answer

Turkey is prized for its lean, mild-flavored meat and its ability to hold moisture during roasting, creating a tender, juicy texture. The skin crisps up, adding a savory, fatty crunch. Replacing it directly is not obvious because no single plant food mimics both the fibrous protein structure and the rendered fat. The goal is not to copy turkey exactly but to create a centerpiece that satisfies the same role: substantial, savory, and celebratory.

Whole roasted cauliflower offers a dramatic, carve-able centerpiece with a nutty, mild flavor, but it lacks protein density and can be watery if not properly dried and seasoned. Stuffed seitan roasts, often wrapped in pastry or phyllo, provide a chewy, meaty texture and high protein, but can be dense and require careful cooking to avoid a rubbery feel. Store-bought options vary widely in price and taste; homemade versions are cheaper and more customizable. Both have a lower carbon footprint than turkey.

For a cauliflower roast, dry-brine it overnight with salt and herbs, then roast at high heat until deeply browned and tender. For seitan, simmer gently in broth rather than boiling to keep it tender. A rich mushroom gravy and tangy cranberry sauce are essential to add moisture and flavor. Be honest: neither will taste exactly like turkey, but both can be delicious and satisfying. Plan for leftovers, as these roasts reheat well in slices pan-fried until crisp.

At a glance

Quick facts

Quick facts — turkey
Detail	What to know
Protein per serving	20–30 g (seitan)
Cooking time	45–90 minutes
Cost per serving	$3–6 (homemade)
Carbon footprint	~80% lower than turkey
Best for texture	Stuffed seitan roast

In practice

What this means for you

Dry-brine cauliflower overnight with salt, garlic powder, and rosemary for deeper flavor.
Simmer seitan in vegetable broth with soy sauce and sage for a savory, tender roast.
Roast cauliflower at 425°F (220°C) until deeply golden, about 45–60 minutes.
Slice seitan roasts 1/2-inch thick and pan-fry leftovers in a little oil for crisp edges.
Pair with a rich mushroom gravy and tart cranberry sauce to balance the savory centerpiece.

FAQ

Common questions

Can I use tofu or tempeh instead of seitan or cauliflower?

Yes, but they work better as sides or in stuffing. Tofu lacks the structural integrity for a carved roast, and tempeh has a strong, nutty flavor that may not suit a traditional turkey-style meal. Press and marinate them for best results, but expect a different texture and taste.

How do I keep a cauliflower roast from being watery?

Dry-brining is key: rub the cauliflower with salt and let it sit uncovered in the fridge overnight. This draws out moisture. Before roasting, pat it dry thoroughly. Roast at high heat (425°F/220°C) without covering, and avoid steaming it. A dry exterior ensures browning, not sogginess.

Is seitan roast difficult to make from scratch?

It requires some patience but is not difficult. Mix vital wheat gluten with seasonings and broth, knead briefly, then shape and wrap tightly in foil or cheesecloth. Simmer in seasoned broth for about an hour. Let it cool before slicing. The result is far cheaper and more flavorful than most store-bought versions.

What are the best store-bought plant-based turkey roasts?

Look for brands like Tofurky, Field Roast, or Gardein. They vary in texture and flavor; some are stuffed with wild rice or vegetables. Read labels for protein content and sodium. Many are pre-cooked and only need reheating. They are convenient but can be pricier and less customizable than homemade options.

Keep going

Is it vegan? →Vegan city guides →Side-by-side comparisons →

Newsletter

One short letter. Once a month.

A handful of recipes, a story worth your time, and one thing you can do this week. Nothing else.

We never share your email. Unsubscribe in one click.