
Catholic Christianity
Overview
Catholic Christianity — and the animals
Catholicism invites the faithful to recognize the inherent worth of all living beings as part of God's creation. This tradition emphasizes that every creature is connected, and as humans, we are called to a role of responsible stewardship rather than absolute domination. By embracing a plant-based lifestyle, Catholics can embody the mercy and compassion that are central to the Gospel.
The teachings of Pope Francis in his encyclical Laudato Si' serve as a modern clarion call for 'universal communion.' This sense of fraternity excludes no one, teaching that cruelty toward fellow creatures ultimately affects how we treat one another. A compassionate heart recognizes that the risen Christ holds all creatures to himself, directing them toward their own fullness.
Rooted in the Garden of Eden's original plant-based diet and the gentle examples of saints like St. Francis of Assisi, Catholic veganism is a journey of mercy. It is an invitation to move away from a 'Promethean vision' of mastery and toward a life of sobriety and care, where the protection of nature is seen as a vital expression of faith and human dignity.
Principles
Teachings that point towards the plate
Universal Communion
Our hearts must be open to a sense of fraternity that excludes nothing and no one. Indifference or cruelty toward fellow creatures inevitably impacts our relationships with other human beings.
Responsible Stewardship
We must reject the notion that being created in God’s image justifies absolute domination over other creatures. Instead, we are called to be stewards who cherish all life with love and respect.
Inherent Worth
Other creatures are not completely subordinated to human use as if they have no worth in themselves. Every living being has its own value and end in God's radiant presence.
Human Dignity and Mercy
Causing animals to suffer or die needlessly is considered contrary to human dignity. Mercy should be extended to every man, woman, and animal in our time.
Interconnectedness
Peace, justice, and the preservation of creation are three interconnected themes. Everything is related, and we are united in a pilgrimage woven together by God's love.
Sobriety and Care
Approaching nature with awe and wonder leads to a life of sobriety. This prevents us from becoming ruthless exploiters unable to set limits on immediate needs.
““Because all creatures are connected, each must be cherished with love and respect, for all of us as living creatures are dependent on one another.””
““It is contrary to human dignity to cause animals to suffer or die needlessly.””
““We are not God. … [N]owadays we must forcefully reject the notion that our being created in God’s image and given dominion over the earth justifies absolute domination over other creatures.””
““Every act of cruelty towards any creature is ‘contrary to human dignity.’””
““I give you all plants that bear seed everywhere on Earth, and every tree bearing fruit which yields seed: they shall be yours for food.””
““The very flowers of the field and the birds which his human eyes contemplated and admired are now imbued with his radiant presence.””
In practice
The Call of Laudato Si’
In his landmark encyclical, Pope Francis challenges the 'tyrannical anthropocentrism' that has often characterized human relationships with the environment. He argues that the Bible has no place for a worldview that is unconcerned for other creatures. Instead, he highlights that the risen One is mysteriously holding all creatures to himself.
This teaching shifts the focus from animals as mere resources to animals as 'sisters and brothers.' When we view the world through the lens of fraternity, our actions change from consumption to care. The Pope reminds us that we have only one heart, and the same wretchedness that leads to mistreating an animal will eventually show itself in our human relationships.
In practice
Biblical Foundations of Compassion
The Catholic tradition finds its roots in the peaceable kingdom described in Genesis, where God provides a seed-bearing plant-based diet for both humans and animals. This original harmony serves as a blueprint for a world without violence or exploitation.
New Testament teachings also support a mindful approach to consumption. St. Paul’s letters to the Romans and Corinthians suggest that if what we eat causes another to fall or suffer, it is better to abstain. This principle of 'not causing a brother or sister to fall' can be extended to our global community and the creatures within it.
- Genesis 1:29-31: The original plant-based diet given by God.
- 1 Corinthians 8:13: Choosing not to eat meat to avoid causing others to fall.
- Romans 14:21: The virtue of abstaining from meat for the sake of the community.
In practice
The Example of St. Francis of Assisi
St. Francis is perhaps the most iconic figure of animal compassion in the Catholic tradition. To him, every creature was a sister or brother united by bonds of affection. His response to the world was not one of economic calculus, but of deep, intellectual, and spiritual appreciation.
The kit recounts a powerful story of St. Francis’s remorse: after eating a few bites of chicken, he felt such guilt that he had someone tie a rope around him and drag him through the streets as an act of penance. This radical empathy reminds us that our dietary choices have spiritual weight.
In practice
Mercy in the Holy Year
During the Jubilee of Mercy, the Church was called to rediscover God's mercy and render it fruitful. This mercy is not limited to humans; it is a comfort we are called to give to every animal in our time.
By entrusting our journey to the 'Mother of Mercy,' Catholics are encouraged to watch their path and ensure it is one of kindness. This includes looking at the systemic ways animals are treated and seeking to bring them under the gaze of God's compassion.
In practice
The Catechism and Human Dignity
The Catechism of the Catholic Church provides a clear framework for our relationship with the animal kingdom. In paragraph 2416, it is noted that animals are God’s creatures, and He surrounds them with His providential care. By their very existence, they bless Him and give Him glory. Thus, men owe them kindness. We are reminded that the way we treat animals reflects our own internal dignity and our capacity for stewardship.
Furthermore, paragraph 2418 explicitly states that it is contrary to human dignity to cause animals to suffer or die needlessly. This teaching suggests that as our society evolves to a point where animal products are no longer necessary for survival or health, the 'need' to cause suffering diminishes. Choosing a plant-based path becomes a way to align our daily habits with the virtue of temperance and the respect due to all of God's handiwork.
In practice
A Eucharistic Vision of Creation
In Catholic theology, the world is seen as sacramental—a sign of God's invisible grace. Pope Francis suggests in Laudato Si’ that the destiny of all creatures is bound up in the mystery of Christ. He notes that the Risen One is mysteriously holding all things to himself and directing them towards fullness as their end. This implies that animals are not merely objects for consumption, but fellow travelers in a cosmic journey toward God.
When we approach the table, we are invited to consider how our food choices reflect this 'universal communion.' A diet that seeks to minimize harm honors the radiant presence of the Creator in all living things. By opting for the fruits of the earth, we participate in a vision of peace that mirrors the Garden of Eden, where, as Genesis 1:29 describes, the original diet given by God was plant-based.
In practice
Social Justice and the Care of Workers
Catholic Social Teaching emphasizes the 'Option for the Poor and Vulnerable.' This principle extends to the workers within the industrial food system. Modern slaughterhouse and factory farm labor is often performed by marginalized communities and immigrants, frequently in dangerous conditions that can lead to physical injury and psychological trauma. A plant-based lifestyle supports a shift toward agricultural systems that can be more humane for human laborers.
Additionally, the Church teaches that the goods of the earth are meant for all. Because animal agriculture is resource-intensive—requiring vast amounts of grain and water that could otherwise directly feed the hungry—choosing a plant-based diet is an act of solidarity. It is a practical way to practice the 'sobriety and care' called for by the Church to ensure that the earth's resources are distributed more equitably among the human family.
In practice
The Ethics of Dairy and Eggs
While traditional fasting rules in the Church have often focused on 'flesh meat,' modern Catholics are increasingly looking at the lives of animals in the dairy and egg industries. The Church teaches that we must forcefully reject the notion that 'dominion' justifies absolute domination. In modern systems, the bond between mother and calf is often severed, and creatures are treated as mere 'consumers and ruthless exploiters' would treat them, rather than as sisters and brothers in creation.
Refraining from dairy and eggs can be seen as an extension of the 'responsible stewardship' mentioned in Laudato Si’. By moving away from these products, we withdraw our support from systems that treat sentient beings as mere biological machines. This reflects a heart that is 'authentically open to universal communion,' excluding nothing and no one from our circle of concern.
In practice
Health as Stewardship of the Body
The Catholic tradition views the body as a 'temple of the Holy Spirit.' Caring for one’s health is not an act of vanity but a form of stewardship that allows us to better serve God and our neighbor. Research into plant-based nutrition shows significant benefits in preventing chronic illnesses, which aligns with the Catholic duty to cherish the gift of life.
Choosing wholesome, plant-derived foods is a way to practice the virtue of fortitude and self-control. It allows us to maintain the vitality needed for our vocations and ministries. By nourishing ourselves with the 'green plants' mentioned in scripture, we honor the design of our bodies and the natural bounty provided by the Earth.
In practice
Kind Dialogue Within the Parish
When sharing the message of plant-based living within a parish, it is important to lead with the 'joy of the Gospel.' Rather than approaching the topic with judgment, we can frame it as a spiritual invitation to deeper mercy. St. Francis of Assisi did not preach through condemnation, but through a 'language of fraternity and beauty' that made others want to join his pilgrimage of care.
We can encourage our communities by highlighting how plant-based meals can be a beautiful part of parish life, from meatless Fridays to Lenten soup suppers. By focusing on the 'bonds of affection' that unite us to all creatures, we help our fellow parishioners see that protecting nature is not just for the 'faint-hearted,' but is a core requirement of a living faith.
Food
Plant-based food in this tradition
- Plant-based Lenten meals: Thousands of Catholics pledge to eat vegan during the 40 days of Lent.
- Vegan Easter Candy: Choosing 'bunny-approved' sweets that contain no animal products.
- Eggnots: Ceramic or non-animal alternatives to traditional Easter eggs for dyeing and decorating.
- St. Francis Feast Day Potluck: Plant-based dishes served on October 4th to honor the patron saint of animals.
- Biblical 'Garden of Eden' Diet: Focusing on fruits, vegetables, seeds, and nuts as described in Genesis 1:29.
- Sobriety in Eating: A focus on simple, plant-based foods to avoid the 'ruthless exploitation' of nature.
- Traditional Lenten 'Columba di Pasqua' (Easter Dove bread) can be made vegan using olive oil and plant milks to symbolize peace.
- Many Italian-Catholic traditions feature 'Pasta e Fagioli' or 'Minestrone,' which are naturally plant-based and hearty staples for meatless Fridays.
- During the Feast of St. Francis, offer 'blessed bread' or fruit baskets to emphasize the bounty of the earth that does not require harm.
- Explore the 'Seven Fishes' Christmas Eve tradition by substituting plant-based seafood alternatives or focusing on the traditional vegetable sides like fried artichokes and marinated peppers.
- Incorporate ancient grains like farro and barley, which were staples in biblical times, into parish communal meals.
Action
What a community can do
- 1Adopt a plant-based diet for Lent as a form of spiritual discipline.
- 2Read and discuss the Laudato Si’ encyclical in your parish social justice group.
- 3Celebrate the Feast of St. Francis (Oct 4th) with a vegan potluck.
- 4Pray for the protection of all creatures using the 'Prayers for Creation' resources.
- 5Choose 'Bunny-approved' vegan candy and wooden 'Eggnots' for Easter celebrations.
- 6Support Catholic organizations that advocate for animal welfare, such as Catholic Concern for Animals.
- 7Reflect on the Catechism's teaching regarding the needless suffering of animals before making food purchases.
- 8Incorporate animal-focused liturgies into special prayer services.
- 9Share resources like 'The Non-Violent Life' by Father John Dear with your community.
- 10Practice 'responsible stewardship' by reducing your environmental footprint through plant-based eating.
- 11Study the lives of vegetarian Christian saints for inspiration.
- 12Advocate for animal protection as an extension of pro-life and social justice values.
- 13Incorporate prayers for animals and the environment into the Universal Prayer (Prayers of the Faithful) during Mass.
- 14Organize a parish 'Care for Creation' potluck featuring exclusively plant-based traditional recipes.
- 15Use beeswax-free or soy-based candles for devotional purposes to avoid animal-derived products in the sanctuary.
- 16Host a study group for the encyclical Laudato Si’ with a specific focus on the sections regarding animal welfare.
- 17Volunteer at or donate to animal sanctuaries as a form of corporal work of mercy.
Resources
Read, watch, connect
Books
- Dominion: The Power of Man, the Suffering of Animals, and the Call to Mercy — Matthew Scully
- Mind if I Order the Cheeseburger? (Specifically Ch. 9) — Sherry F. Colb
- Peace to All Beings: Veggie Soup for The Chicken’s Soul — Judy Carman
- The Dominion of Love: Animal Rights According to the Bible — Norm Phelps
- The Lost Religion of Jesus — Keith Akers
- The School of Compassion: A Roman Catholic Theology of Animals — Deborah M. Jones
- Vegetarian Christian Saints — Holly Roberts
- For the Love of Animals — Charles Camosy
Films & talks
- Catholic Social teaching and Animal Rights with Dr. Charlie Camosy — A lecture from a Georgetown University professor on the theological basis for animal rights.
- Father Frank Mann Vegan Awakening — A video detailing a priest's journey toward veganism.
- Honoring God’s Creation — A resource for understanding the spiritual dimensions of our relationship with nature.
- Main Street Vegan: Catholic Vegan Mom and Charles Camosy — A radio interview discussing the intersection of daily Catholic life and veganism.
Questions